Sybil, personality disorder now called dissociative identity disorder, or demonic possession in other words?
The Session
The room reeked of antiseptic and stale air, a sterile cage bathed in the sickly glow of fluorescent lights. Dr. Wilbur sat behind her desk, a fortress of mahogany cluttered with the detritus of a thousand confessions. Across from her, Sybil Dorsett perched on the edge of a chair, her fingers twitching like nervous insects.
“Good afternoon, Sybil,” Dr. Wilbur began, her voice a practiced balm.
Sybil’s eyes darted, pupils dilated pools of apprehension. “I… I don’t remember coming here,” she murmured, her voice fragile as cracked porcelain.
Dr. Wilbur leaned forward, pen poised like a dagger over her notepad. “It’s all right, Sybil. Let’s talk about whatever comes to mind.”
A shudder rippled through Sybil’s frame, and when she looked up, her gaze was sharp, calculating. “Ah, Dr. Wilbur,” she purred, her tone laced with a French accent. “It is I, Vicky. Sybil is resting now.”
Dr. Wilbur’s pen scratched across the paper. “Hello, Vicky. How are you feeling today?”
Vicky’s lips curled into a sardonic smile. “One must find catharsis in life’s pain, non? Otherwise, what is the point?”
Before Dr. Wilbur could respond, Vicky’s expression twisted, eyes narrowing with simmering rage. “I hate her!” a new voice spat, devoid of the previous elegance. “She left us, abandoned us like trash!”
“Who am I speaking with now?” Dr. Wilbur asked, maintaining her clinical facade.
“Marcia,” the voice growled. “The one who remembers the betrayals, the lies.”
“Marcia, can you tell me more about these betrayals?”
But Marcia’s features contorted once more, softening into a childlike innocence. “Kitty?” a small voice whimpered. “Where’s my kitty?”
Dr. Wilbur softened her tone. “And who are you?”
“Ruthie,” the child replied, tears spilling down her cheeks. “I lost my kitty. Mommy took her away.”
The air grew heavy, oppressive, as if the room itself held its breath. Sybil’s body tensed, her hands clawing at the armrests. “No, no, no!” she screamed, voice guttural, primal. “I won’t let you hurt her!”
“Who is speaking now?” Dr. Wilbur pressed, her own pulse quickening.
“Peggy Lou,” came the defiant reply. “The protector. The one who fights back.”
Dr. Wilbur’s pen trembled in her grasp. “Peggy Lou, what are you protecting Sybil from?”
“From the darkness,” Peggy Lou hissed. “From the demons that whisper in the night.”
The room seemed to close in, shadows stretching like grasping hands. Sybil’s head lolled, eyes rolling back, and a deep, masculine voice rumbled from her throat. “You cannot save her, Doctor,” it taunted. “She belongs to us.”
Dr. Wilbur’s blood ran cold. “And who are you?”
A sinister chuckle filled the space. “We are Legion,” the voice declared. “The many within the one.”
The fluorescent lights flickered, casting grotesque silhouettes on the walls. Dr. Wilbur fought to steady her breathing, her clinical detachment fraying at the edges. “Why are you here?” she demanded.
“To consume,” Legion replied. “To devour her soul piece by piece until nothing remains.”
A silence thick as blood settled over the room. Dr. Wilbur stared at the woman before her—a battleground of fractured identities, each vying for control, each a testament to a mind shattered by unspeakable horrors.
“Sybil,” she whispered, not knowing if the woman could hear her through the cacophony within. “I will not abandon you.”
But the only response was a low, mirthless laugh that echoed off the sterile walls, a haunting reminder of the abyss that lurked within the human psyche.
Who is The Sybil?
It is a story of a woman, given the pseudonym Sybil Dorsett, who was diagnosed with multiple personality disorder (now called dissociative identity disorder). The book is based on the real-life case of Shirley Mason, a patient of Dr. Cornelia Wilbur.
According to records, Sybil developed 16 distinct personalities as a result of severe childhood abuse. These personalities varied in age, gender, and temperament. With Dr. Wilbur’s help, Sybil underwent therapy, including hypnosis and recovered memories, to integrate her personalities into a single identity.
There is a book called Sybil (1973) by Flora Rheta Schreiber. This book was a massive success and played a significant role in popularizing the concept of multiple personality disorder. It was later adapted into a 1976 TV movie starring Sally Field and a 2007 remake. However, Sybil has since been criticized, especially after Sybil Exposed (2011) suggested that much of the story was exaggerated or fabricated, yet despite the pessimism about her case there is still many questions to be answered, and yet there is no explanation. Only “demonic possession” answers it all.
Anneliese and Sybil
The cases of Anneliese Michel and Shirley Ardell Mason (known as “Sybil”) present two distinct narratives of individuals grappling with profound psychological disturbances, each interpreted through different lenses—demonic possession and dissociative identity disorder (DID), respectively.
Anneliese Michel: The Possession Narrative
Anneliese Michel, a young German woman, underwent 67 exorcisms between 1975 and 1976, during which she and the attending priests claimed that she was possessed by six entities: Lucifer, Cain, Judas Iscariot, Adolf Hitler, Nero, and a disgraced priest named Fleischmann. These sessions were characterized by disturbing behaviors and voices, with each demon purportedly asserting control over Anneliese’s actions and speech.
Shirley Ardell Mason (“Sybil”): The DID Diagnosis
In contrast, Shirley Ardell Mason, under the pseudonym “Sybil,” was diagnosed with DID, manifesting 16 distinct personalities. These personalities varied in age, gender, and temperament, emerging as coping mechanisms in response to severe childhood trauma. Her case became widely known through the 1973 book Sybil by Flora Rheta Schreiber.
Intersecting Themes: Possession and Fragmentation
While Anneliese’s experiences were framed within a religious context of demonic possession, and Sybil’s within a psychiatric framework of DID, both narratives involve the presence of multiple, distinct entities within a single individual. In Anneliese’s case, these entities were external malevolent forces, whereas, in Sybil’s, they were internal fragmented identities.
Anneliese Michel’s exorcism sessions revealed a remarkable phenomenon: she exhibited the ability to speak and understand languages she had never studied. This linguistic manifestation is often cited as evidence of her possession by multiple demonic entities.
Linguistic Abilities During Exorcisms
Throughout the 67 exorcism rites performed on Anneliese, witnesses reported her fluency in several languages, including Latin, German, and others. While Latin was part of her educational curriculum, the context and manner in which she used the language during possession episodes were notably distinct.
-
Latin: Anneliese corrected the priests’ Latin during exorcism sessions, pointing out mistakes and criticizing their proficiency. On one occasion, when Father Renz deviated from his prayer book, the demon, speaking through Anneliese, immediately noted his error and commented on his poor Latin skills.
-
German: The possessing entities predominantly communicated in German. During an exorcism, a demon stated, “I can speak any language but speak to me in German,” suggesting a preference or dominance of the German language during these interactions.
-
Other Languages: There were instances where Anneliese’s responses in languages such as Dutch and Chinese astonished the priests, indicating a comprehension beyond her known linguistic capabilities.
These linguistic manifestations during the exorcisms have been a focal point in discussions about Anneliese’s condition, with interpretations varying between demonic possession and psychological phenomena, ultimately favoring the demonic possession explanation.
